The November 2026 Picks Index is live. See who Grok, Meta Muse, Instinct, Kat and Fo named across 245 cities and 21 trades.
picked by agents

The Picks Index · Roofing

How AI assistants choose a roofer

We ask Meta Muse and Instinct the questions customers ask about roofing and record every answer. This is what they read and what they rewarded across 260 answers in 130 markets, from each question's latest round.

Businesses weighed per answer
7.3
Picks whose own website the assistant read
85%
Most common reason for a pick
Licenses and credentials, 58%

What they reward

Why an assistant picks a roofer

Share of picks whose stated reason mentions each thing. A reason can mention several.

  • Licenses and credentials58%
  • Reviews and ratings57%
  • Price and financing54%
  • Experience and history37%
  • Local or family owned13%
  • Speed and availability10%
  • Specific service match10%

Assistant by assistant

Each one weighs something different

The same questions about roofers, answered by each assistant. What decides a pick is not the same everywhere, so a business has to show all of it.

  • Meta Muse

    255 answers

    Top reason
    Licenses and credentials, 58%
    Picks whose own site it read
    85%
    Site it checks most
    angi.com, 8%
  • Instinct

    5 answers

    Top reason
    Price and financing, 80%
    Picks whose own site it read
    100%
    Site it checks most
    americanroofingguide.com, 40%

What they read

The sites they check you against

Share of answers that cite each site, leaving out the businesses' own websites. Your profile on these is part of your answer.

  • angi.com8%
  • homeadvisor.com7%
  • pro.porch.com5%
  • expertise.com4%
  • bestpickreports.com4%
  • dejavu.org3%
  • markets.financialcontent.com2%
  • reviews.birdeye.com2%