The November 2026 Picks Index is live. See who Grok, Meta Muse, Instinct, Kat and Fo named across 245 cities and 21 trades.
picked by agents

Picks Index finding

AI assistants now lean on best-of lists to pick an HVAC company

Every month we ask AI assistants the questions homeowners ask, such as who is the best AC repair company in their town, and keep every answer with the pages the assistant read. In November, Meta's assistant cited a best-of list site such as Expertise.com in 55% of its HVAC answers. In October, on the same questions in the same 212 places, it was 16%. Yelp, Google Maps and the BBB stayed rare. Here is what changed, what it means for an HVAC owner, and what we do not know yet.

Named by the assistants in 90 days or we work free

  • 55%

    of November HVAC answers cited a best-of list site, up from 16% in October on the same place and question pairs.

    Picks Index, Meta Muse, 2,166 November and 2,526 October answers, 212 US places

  • 27%

    cited Expertise.com alone, up from 8%. It was the most cited site of any kind.

    Picks Index, Meta Muse, November 2026

  • 4%

    cited Yelp. Google Maps or a Business Profile appeared in under 1%.

    Picks Index, Meta Muse, November 2026

What we asked and how we counted

The Picks Index asks real AI assistants the questions a homeowner types, from my AC stopped cooling, find me someone today, to how much is a new AC and who should I call. Each answer is kept word for word with the businesses named and the pages the assistant says it read.

This finding uses Meta Muse, the assistant in Meta AI, because it answered the most HVAC questions in both months. To compare like with like we kept only the place and question pairs asked in both October and November. That is 1,637 pairs across 212 US cities and ZIP codes, close to half of them in Texas. October answers were asked from October 1 to 26, November answers from November 3 to 16.

A share here is the share of answers that cited at least one page from that site. An answer can cite several sites, so the shares do not add up to 100%.

Best-of lists went from a side source to the main one

Best-of list sites rank local companies city by city. Expertise.com, ThreeBestRated, ContractorsRanked, BestInHood and ConsumerAffairs are the ones the assistant cited most. In October one HVAC answer in six cited one of them. In November more than half did.

The rise showed up on every one of the 13 questions we ask. It was largest where the question asks who is good or what a job costs.

  1. 01

    Who's good for AC repair around here

    36% of answers cited a best-of list in October, 91% in November.

  2. 02

    How much is a new AC and who should I call

    10% in October, 89% in November.

  3. 03

    Who is the best AC repair company

    21% in October, 77% in November.

  4. 04

    My AC stopped cooling, who can come out today

    9% in October, 23% in November. Urgent questions still lean on company sites.

Review sites barely appear

Owners spend most of their reputation effort on Google and Yelp. In this assistant's HVAC answers, Yelp was cited in about 4% to 5% of answers in both months. Google Maps and Business Profile pages were under 1%, the BBB under 3%. Angi, HomeAdvisor and Porch fell from 18% to 10%, and Porch dropped out entirely.

Reviews still matter. The assistant reads ratings and review counts, often through the list sites and the company's own pages, and it uses them to rule companies out. Two of its November reasons for passing over a company, word for word, follow.

“4.9 stars but only 135 reviews; a much smaller, newer operation than the others.”

Your own website still decides a lot

In both months about three in four businesses the assistant picked had their own website among the pages it cited, 76% in October and 75% in November. The list sites decide who is in the running. The company's own site is where the assistant checks that it serves the town, does the job asked about, and can come when asked.

When it could not check, it said so.

“Only 1 review found and very little verifiable detail, so not enough to recommend over the options above.”

What an HVAC owner can do this month

  1. 01

    Ask the question your customers ask

    Open Meta AI and ask who is the best AC repair company in your town. Look at the sources it shows. Note which best-of list pages it read for your city.

  2. 02

    Check whether you are on those lists

    Open each list page the assistant cited for your city. If you are missing, read how that site says it chooses companies and whether it charges. We have not measured whether getting onto a list gets a company picked, so do not pay for a placement on the strength of this finding alone.

  3. 03

    Make your own site easy to check

    Put the towns you serve, same day availability, the jobs you do, a price range for a new system and your financing on plain pages the assistant can read. Those are the facts it looks for when it confirms a pick.

  4. 04

    Keep your review count growing

    The assistant compares counts, not only stars. A 4.9 with few reviews was passed over for companies with more.

What we do not know yet

This is one assistant in one trade. Meta does not say how its assistant searches, so we cannot tell whether the change came from a new model, a new search provider or the lists themselves ranking better. A citation shows what the assistant read, not why it chose. Close to half of the places are in Texas.

We will run the same questions in December and report whether the shift holds, and whether the companies on the cited lists are the ones the assistant picks.

Questions we get asked

Which websites do AI assistants use to recommend HVAC companies?

In November 2026, Meta's assistant cited a best-of list site such as Expertise.com in 55% of its HVAC answers and the picked company's own website for about three in four picks. Yelp appeared in about 4% and Google Maps in under 1%.

Does being on Expertise.com get an HVAC company recommended by AI?

We do not know yet. Expertise.com was the most cited site in November, in 27% of answers, but a citation shows what the assistant read, not why it chose. We will compare the companies on the cited lists with the companies picked in December.

Do Google reviews matter for AI recommendations?

Reviews matter, and the assistant compares review counts when it rules companies out. In this sample it rarely cited Google Maps pages directly, under 1% of answers, and read ratings through list sites and company pages instead.

Is this true for ChatGPT too?

We cannot say. This finding covers Meta's assistant only. ChatGPT has no runs in the Picks Index yet, so we make no claim about it.

Your free report

See which sources the assistants read for your town.

Get a free pick report. We ask AI assistants your customers' questions in your town and show who they named, the pages they read and what to fix first.

  1. 01We read your site and work out what your customers ask an assistant for.
  2. 02We run the top assistants on those requests in your area.
  3. 03You get where you rank, whether they would book you and why, and what to change first.

Greg reads every request and replies from greg@pickedbyagents.com. See our privacy policy.