The November 2026 Picks Index is live. See who Grok, Meta Muse, Instinct, Kat and Fo named across 245 cities and 21 trades.
picked by agents

vs Merchynt

Paige runs your Google profile. We work on who the assistant names, and why.

Merchynt makes Paige, AI software that keeps a Google Business Profile busy. It writes posts, replies to reviews, tracks Maps rankings and reports each month, for one flat price. We do a different job. We ask AI assistants the question your customer asks, keep the answer and the reason, and make the facts on your own website easy for an assistant to read.

Named by the assistants in 90 days or we work free

  • 90%

    of the businesses AI assistants picked were named from their own site

    Picks Index, 729 first picks across 139 markets, September 2026

  • 45%

    of consumers have used AI tools for local business recommendations, up from 6%

    BrightLocal Local Consumer Review Survey, February 2026, n=1,002 opt-in panel

  • 32%

    of local business sites show a price

    Picked by Agents live sample, 236 sites in Dallas and Phoenix, September 2026

What each of us actually does

Paige is $99 a month per Google Business Profile, with no contract and a 3 day free trial. By Merchynt's pages it optimizes the profile, writes and publishes posts, replies to reviews, suggests listing fixes, tracks Google Maps rankings and includes a hosted website. Posts and replies can wait for your approval or run on autopilot. It sends monthly AI rank reports for ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Grok, Llama and Claude. Citation management is a $40 a month add-on. Merchynt states that rankings, calls and AI recommendations are not guaranteed. Agencies can white label Paige, and a separate Agency Partner Program is $100 a month.

Picked by Agents starts with a free pick report. We run your customers' real questions through AI assistants and show who got named and the reason the assistant gave. The AI-ready plugin, $299 a month, tracks how AI assistants and Google see your business, checks your website every week and makes the fixes it can for you, from one install on the site you already have. White glove, $2,990 a month, puts a team on your site, listings and booking path, with six written guarantees. Both are month to month.

Where the two approaches part

  1. 01

    Google first vs assistants first

    Merchynt says most local searches still happen on Google, so Paige covers Google first and AI alongside it. We start from the assistant's answer and work back to what it could not find.

  2. 02

    The profile vs your own site

    Paige works on the Google Business Profile and gives you a hosted website. We work with the website you already have. In our Picks Index, 90% of picked businesses were named from their own site.

  3. 03

    A rank report vs the stated reason

    Paige reports whether AI engines recommend you each month. Our report quotes the assistant, names the business it chose instead and keeps the reason it gave, which is usually a missing price, opening or service area.

  4. 04

    No guarantee vs a named guarantee

    Merchynt says plainly that AI recommendations are not guaranteed. Our plugin carries no guarantee either. White glove guarantees you are named within 90 days or we keep working free. We never promise revenue.

When Merchynt is the better choice

If your Google Business Profile sits untouched, reviews go unanswered and you want that handled for $99 a month, Paige does it and costs a third of our plugin. If you have no website, its hosted site is a fast start. If your profile is in good shape and the assistants still name a competitor, we show you why and fix what your own site is missing.

Merchynt Paige vs Picked by Agents

Merchynt PaigePicked by Agents
What it isAI software that manages a Google Business ProfileWork on being the business AI assistants name
Price$99 a month per profile, 3 day free trial$299 a month plugin, $2,990 a month white glove
Your websiteA hosted website is includedYour current site, unchanged
AI reportingMonthly AI rank reports across six enginesWho assistants named on your questions, with the reason
GuaranteeStates that AI recommendations are not guaranteedNamed in 90 days or we work free, on white glove
TermsNo contract, cancel anytimeMonth to month

Questions we get asked

Is Picked by Agents a Merchynt alternative?

Not for Google Business Profile management. Paige posts, replies to reviews and tracks Maps rankings, and we do none of that on the plugin. We are for the owner who wants the assistant's reason for passing and wants their own site read correctly.

Do you report on the same AI engines as Paige?

No. Merchynt lists ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Grok, Llama and Claude for its AI rank reports. Our network runs its own assistant accounts, including Meta Muse and Instinct, and we only report what those runs recorded.

Can we use both?

Yes. Paige keeps the profile active and we work on the website's facts. One thing to check first. Merchynt says websites it hosts cannot be exported, so our plugin is meant for a site you own on your own domain.

Where do your facts about Merchynt come from?

Its home page, its Paige page and its agencies page, read in November 2026. The 90% and 32% are from our Picks Index and live sample, and the 45% from BrightLocal's published survey. If Merchynt changes its plans, tell us and we will correct this page.

Your free report

See which business the assistants name in your town.

The first pick report is free. If an unmanaged Google profile is your gap, Paige is the better first buy, and we will say so.

  1. 01We read your site and work out what your customers ask an assistant for.
  2. 02We run the top assistants on those requests in your area.
  3. 03You get where you rank, whether they would book you and why, and what to change first.

Greg reads every request and replies from greg@pickedbyagents.com. See our privacy policy.