The November 2026 Picks Index is live. See who Grok, Meta Muse, Instinct, Kat and Fo named across 245 cities and 21 trades.
picked by agents

Guide for owners

How to choose a local SEO company

Choose a local SEO company the way Google itself suggests. Ask for past work and references, ask what results to expect and how they will be measured, and walk away from anyone who guarantees a ranking. Keep ownership of your domain, website, Google Business Profile and analytics, and get the services and costs in writing. In 2026 a good one can also show you what AI assistants say about your business.

Named by the assistants in 90 days or we work free

  • 45%

    of US consumers used an AI tool for local business recommendations in the past year, up from 6% the year before.

    BrightLocal, Local Consumer Review Survey 2026, n=1,002 US adults

  • 43%

    of consumers checked Google after getting an AI recommendation. Only 2% use AI as their only channel.

    BrightLocal, July 2026, n=1,227

Before you search for an SEO company near you

Know what you are buying. Google's own page on hiring an SEO lists the work. Reviewing your site's content and structure, technical advice, content development, campaign management, keyword research, training, expertise in a market or region, and optimizing for generative AI.

Google says a great time to hire is when you are planning a site redesign or a new site, the earlier the better. It also says to read its SEO starter guide first so you can recognize techniques it discourages.

Two facts from Google clear up most sales calls. No one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google. And advertising with Google has no effect on your site's presence in its search results. For the map, Google says there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking.

Near you matters less than it sounds. The company does not need an office in your town. It needs to know your trade and your market, which is one of the questions below.

The questions to ask

These come from Google's list of questions for a prospective SEO. Ask them on the first call and write down the answers.

  1. 01

    Can you show me past work and success stories?

    Then call the references. Google suggests asking past clients whether the service was useful, whether the company was easy to work with and whether it produced results.

  2. 02

    Do you follow Google Search Essentials?

    These are Google's published rules. Google warns that deceptive or misleading content can get a site removed from its index, and that you are responsible for what a company you hire does.

  3. 03

    What results do you expect, by when, and how do you measure them?

    Google does not publish a timeline, so get theirs in writing. Google says an audit should give you realistic estimates of improvement and of the work involved.

  4. 04

    What is your experience in my industry and my city?

    Ask for an example from a business like yours. Google also suggests asking how long the company has been in business.

  5. 05

    How will you communicate, and will you tell me every change you make?

    Google says to ask whether they will share all the changes they make to your site and the reasoning behind them.

  6. 06

    What do you want to know about my business?

    Google says a good SEO is interested in you. Your business, your competitors and how customers find you now. No questions is a bad sign.

What you should own

The work should build things you keep. Before you sign, check who holds each of these. If the answer is the company, ask to have it moved to your account first.

“If you stop paying and lose your site, your profile or your data, you were renting, not hiring.”
  1. 01

    Your domain

    Registered in your name, in an account you can log in to. This is our advice, not a Google rule. Everything else points at the domain.

  2. 02

    Your website

    Ask plainly whether you keep the site, its content and its logins if you leave. Google says that if an SEO has FTP access to your server, they should be willing to explain every change they make.

  3. 03

    Your Google Business Profile

    You stay the owner and the company is added as a manager. Google says managers can edit, post and reply to reviews but cannot add or remove people or remove the profile. Third parties cannot access a profile without your permission.

  4. 04

    Your Search Console

    Owners control who has access and can remove anyone. For an audit, Google says to grant read access only, not write access.

  5. 05

    Your analytics

    In Google Analytics only an Administrator can add or delete users. Be an Administrator on your own account and give the company a lower role.

Contract terms to read and the warning signs

Google's advice for profile services applies to any SEO contract. Get a copy of the agreement that clearly details the services and their costs. A bill above the agreed price is a warning sign.

Then read for the terms Google does not cover. How long you are committed, how you cancel, what happens to the site and content when you do, and exactly what work is done each month. These are questions to ask, and any honest company can answer them in one email.

Google names its own warning signs. A guaranteed ranking. A claimed special relationship with Google or a priority submit. A tool said to be approved by Google, which Google says it does not do. Unsolicited emails from SEO firms. Link schemes or mass submissions to search engines. A requirement that you link to the SEO. Google says that if an audit promises first place, find someone else.

If you were misled, Google points US businesses to the Federal Trade Commission, which takes complaints about deceptive or unfair business practices at ftc.gov.

What reporting should show, including AI assistants

A report should show what was done and what changed, in numbers you can open yourself. For the profile, Google reports views, the search terms people used, calls, direction requests, website clicks, messages and bookings. Google says you have the right to know these. For the site, Google says to verify it in Search Console, which you should own, to find and diagnose technical issues.

Ask one more question in 2026. What do AI assistants say when a customer asks who to hire in my town? Google now lists optimizing for generative AI among the things an SEO may do, and says to check any advice on AI experiences against its own guidance. That guidance says there are no special requirements for AI Overviews or AI Mode beyond good SEO, and that keeping your Business Profile information up to date is a best practice.

So a local SEO company does not need a secret AI method. It should be able to show you the actual answers, who was named, and the reasons given. If yours cannot, our free pick report does exactly that. We also sell monthly plans, and you can use the report without buying one.

Questions we get asked

How do I find a good SEO company near me?

Ask for past work and references in your trade, ask what results to expect and how they are measured, and call the references. Rule out anyone who guarantees a ranking or claims a special relationship with Google. Keep ownership of your domain, site, profile and analytics.

Can an SEO company guarantee first page rankings on Google?

No. Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and that you should be wary of companies that claim guaranteed rankings or a special relationship with Google. If an audit promises first place, Google says to find someone else.

How long does local SEO take to work?

Google's guidance for hiring an SEO gives no timeline. It tells you to ask each company what results to expect and in what timeframe. Get that answer in writing and compare it with what the references say happened for them.

What access should I give a local SEO company?

Manager access on your Google Business Profile, not ownership. Read access to Search Console for the audit, as Google advises. A role below Administrator in Google Analytics. You can remove each of these yourself if you part ways.

Should a local SEO company handle AI search too?

It should at least show you what AI assistants say about your business. Google lists optimizing for generative AI as work an SEO may do, and says its AI features need no special optimization beyond sound SEO and an up to date Business Profile.

Your free report

Bring one more thing to the sales call.

Get a free pick report. We run real customer questions through AI assistants and show who gets picked, why, and what to fix first. Use it to judge any company you are thinking of hiring.

  1. 01We read your site and work out what your customers ask an assistant for.
  2. 02We run the top assistants on those requests in your area.
  3. 03You get where you rank, whether they would book you and why, and what to change first.

Greg reads every request and replies from greg@pickedbyagents.com. See our privacy policy.