The November 2026 Picks Index is live. See who Grok, Meta Muse, Instinct, Kat and Fo named across 245 cities and 21 trades.
picked by agents

vs Smith.ai

Smith.ai answers the call. We work on who the assistant tells them to call.

Smith.ai is a receptionist service. Its AI and its live agents pick up, qualify the caller and book the appointment, around the clock. We do not sell a receptionist of any kind. We work one step earlier. When a customer asks an AI assistant who to call, we find out whether it named you, and we make your business easier for it to name.

Named by the assistants in 90 days or we work free

  • 45%

    of consumers have used AI tools for local business recommendations, up from 6%

    BrightLocal Local Consumer Review Survey, February 2026, n=1,002 opt-in panel

  • 25%

    of local business sites let a customer book online

    Picked by Agents live sample, 236 sites in Dallas and Phoenix, September 2026

  • 90%

    of the businesses AI assistants picked were named from their own site

    Picks Index, 729 first picks across 139 markets, September 2026

What each of us actually does

Smith.ai offers three ways to have calls handled. AI-first starts at $1.60 a call, hybrid at $2.50 and human-first at $7, by its home page. The AI Receptionist screens callers, qualifies leads, books appointments and makes warm transfers, 24 hours a day, in English and Spanish. Its plans are Free at $0 with 25 calls, Pro at $150 a month with 75 calls and Enterprise at $500 a month with 300. The live-staffed plans run from Starter at $300 a month for 30 calls to Pro at $2,100 for 300, with a 30 day money-back guarantee for new clients up to $1,000. Plans are month to month. Smith.ai says it serves over 5,000 law firms and also lists home services, IT, marketing agencies and other industries.

Picked by Agents does not answer phones. The free pick report runs your customers' real questions through AI assistants and shows who got named and why. The AI-ready plugin, $299 a month, tracks how AI assistants and Google see your business, checks your website every week and makes the fixes it can for you, from one install on the site you already have. White glove, $2,990 a month, adds a team that fixes your site, listings and booking path, with six written guarantees. Both are month to month.

Where the two approaches part

  1. 01

    After the ring vs before it

    Smith.ai starts working when your phone rings. We work on the moment before, when the customer asks an assistant who to call and the assistant chooses a name.

  2. 02

    Your AI vs the customer's AI

    Smith.ai's AI Receptionist speaks for your business. The assistants we run questions through speak for the customer, and they decide which business gets the call.

  3. 03

    Per call vs per month

    Smith.ai prices by the call, with included calls and a rate for each call over. Our two plans are flat monthly prices that do not move with call volume.

  4. 04

    Two different guarantees

    Smith.ai offers new clients of its live-staffed plans their money back in the first 30 days, up to $1,000. Our white glove guarantee is that you are named in your customers' questions within 90 days or we keep working free. We never promise revenue.

When Smith.ai is the better choice

If calls already come in and go to voicemail, or your front desk cannot keep up with intake, Smith.ai solves that and we do not. Buy the receptionist first. If the phone is quiet because the assistants name a competitor, a better receptionist will not change that, and we fit. Many businesses would use both, and nothing about one gets in the way of the other.

Smith.ai vs Picked by Agents

Smith.aiPicked by Agents
What it isAI and live receptionists that answer your callsWork on being the business AI assistants name
PriceAI plans from $0 to $500 a month, live-staffed from $300 to $2,100$299 a month plugin, $2,990 a month white glove
Where it worksAfter a customer calls youBefore, when the customer asks an assistant who to call
Answers your phoneYes, 24 hours a dayNo. We do not sell a receptionist
Guarantee30 day money-back for new clients, up to $1,000Named in 90 days or we work free, on white glove
TermsMonth to monthMonth to month

Questions we get asked

Is Picked by Agents a Smith.ai alternative?

No. Smith.ai answers, qualifies and books the callers who reach you. We do not sell an AI receptionist or a live one. We work on whether AI assistants name your business when a customer asks who to call.

Does Smith.ai help me get recommended by AI assistants?

The Smith.ai pages we read describe call answering, intake, scheduling and transfers. They make no claim about being named by AI assistants, so we make none for them.

Can we use both?

Yes. Keep Smith.ai on the phones. Our plugin does not touch your website or your phone setup, and the free report only needs your business, your services and the place you serve.

Where do your facts about Smith.ai come from?

Its home page, its pricing pages and its AI Receptionist page, read in November 2026. The 45% is from BrightLocal's published survey, and the 25% and 90% from our live sample and Picks Index. If Smith.ai changes its plans, tell us and we will correct this page.

Your free report

See whether the assistants send callers your way.

The first pick report is free. If your gap is unanswered calls, Smith.ai is the better first buy, and we will say so.

  1. 01We read your site and work out what your customers ask an assistant for.
  2. 02We run the top assistants on those requests in your area.
  3. 03You get where you rank, whether they would book you and why, and what to change first.

Greg reads every request and replies from greg@pickedbyagents.com. See our privacy policy.