The November 2026 Picks Index is live. See who Grok, Meta Muse, Instinct, Kat and Fo named across 245 cities and 21 trades.
picked by agents

Picked by Agents index · Roofing in Indianapolis, IN

“Find three roofers in Indianapolis, IN for an asphalt-shingle roof replacement. Compare published pricing, credentials, warranties and availability for an inspection.”

We asked Meta Muse this exact question in October 2026. Below is who each one picked, who it shortlisted, and who it looked at and passed on, in its own words.

Meta Muse

United States · Meta Muse via a research connector · asked 2026-10-07 20:54 UTC

  1. searched best roofing companies Indianapolis IN asphalt shingle replacement reviews warranty
  2. read 4 pages
    • https://indyroofandrestoration.com/the-10-best-roofing-companies-in-indianapolis-for-2026/
    • https://bestofindianapolis.net/best-roofing-companies-in-indianapolis/
    • https://www.roofitforward.com/indianapolis/asphalt-shingle-roofing
    • https://jdhostetter.com/roofing/
Amos Exteriors's page as the assistant saw it
Picked

Amos Exteriors

indyroofandrestoration.com
“Serving Central Indiana since 1971 as a GAF Master Elite Contractor authorized to offer the Golden Pledge warranty, combining half a century of warranty security with manufacturer-backed workmanship coverage.”
North American Contractors's page as the assistant saw it
Shortlisted · choice 2

North American Contractors

indyroofandrestoration.com
“Serving Greater Indianapolis since 2002, one of few local companies holding GAF Master Elite certification, with a long-standing A+ BBB rating across hundreds of verified reviews.”
ARAC Roof It Forward's page as the assistant saw it
Passed

ARAC Roof It Forward

roofitforward.com
“4.8 across 2701 reviews with Platinum Preferred warranty status and free video inspections, but serves Indianapolis from a Noblesville office and scored just behind the picks.”
JD Hostetter & Associates's page as the assistant saw it
Passed

JD Hostetter & Associates

jdhostetter.com
“Locally owned since 2004, Malarkey Premium Pro Certified, A+ BBB with GuildQuality scores above 95%, but narrower manufacturer warranty story than the GAF Master Elite picks.”
A1 Roofing Indiana's page as the assistant saw it
Passed

A1 Roofing Indiana

bestofindianapolis.net
“GAF and Owens Corning Preferred Contractor with strong hail-damage insurance coordination, but Preferred is a lower certification tier than the Master Elite picks.”

Meta Muse

Meta Muse via a research connector · asked 2026-10-10 07:07 UTC

  1. searched roof replacement Indianapolis IN asphalt shingles pricing
  2. searched best roofers Indianapolis IN warranty GAF Owens Corning certified
  3. read 8 pages
    • https://staydryroofing.com/indianapolis-roof-replacement-cost-calculator-2026/
    • https://bigboysconstructioninc.com/
    • https://jdhostetter.com/roofing/
    • https://oc-roofing.com
    • https://www.camsroofing.com/blog/uncategorized/calculating-the-cost-of-a-roof-replacement-in-indianapolis-in/
    • https://allthatroofingin.com/roofing-services/roof-replacement/
    • https://www.jacksoncontractingsite.com/roof-replacement/factors-that-can-affect-roof-replacement/
    • https://a-1roofingnow.com/directory/indy-rooftops-llc/
Big Boy's Construction's page as the assistant saw it
Picked

Big Boy's Construction

bigboysconstructioninc.com
“GAF Master Elite certification (held by only 2% of US roofers) with published warranty tiers including a lifetime limited warranty and the 50-year non-prorated Golden Pledge option, plus a free roof inspection offer; published pricing was not found.”
JD Hostetter & Associates's page as the assistant saw it
Shortlisted · choice 2

JD Hostetter & Associates

jdhostetter.com
“The only Malarkey Emerald Premium Pro contractor in Indianapolis, publishing a limited lifetime warranty with 15 years of full labor and material coverage, A+ BBB rating, and free storm-damage inspections; published pricing was not found.”
Stay Dry Roofing's page as the assistant saw it
Shortlisted · choice 3

Stay Dry Roofing

staydryroofing.com
“The only candidate with published Indianapolis pricing ($4.50-$7.50 per sq ft installed, $9,000-$15,000 for a 2,000 sq ft architectural-shingle roof), plus free inspections and stated workmanship warranties; manufacturer certifications were not published.”
O C Roofing Services's page as the assistant saw it
Passed

O C Roofing Services

oc-roofing.com
“Owens Corning Preferred Contractor and BBB accreditation with free inspection, but it is a multi-state operation and publishes no specific warranty terms or pricing, so it ranked below the three picks.”
Cams Roofing's page as the assistant saw it
Passed

Cams Roofing

camsroofing.com
“Publishes local pricing guidance only; I did not verify its manufacturer credentials, warranty terms, or inspection availability from its site, so it was not shortlisted.”
ATR Roofing's page as the assistant saw it
Passed

ATR Roofing

allthatroofingin.com
“Publishes 2026 Indianapolis price ranges only; no manufacturer certifications or specific warranty terms were found on the pages reviewed, so it was not shortlisted.”
Passed

Indy Rooftops LLC

a-1roofingnow.com
“Only found through a third-party directory page (not its own site), so credentials, pricing, and warranties could not be verified from a primary source.”

How we ran this

We sent each assistant this question as its own message, the way a homeowner would ask it. It searched the web and read business sites on its own. Each answer shows which assistant and version answered and when. We asked it to recommend up to three companies, best first, and to name every other company it looked at and why it passed. Reasons are quoted as given. Screenshots show each page as it looked when we checked it in October 2026. We ask again every month and keep every answer. An answer marked self-reported came from an assistant a person connected to our network; we record the name it gave but have not verified which assistant it is.

Picked by Agents is not affiliated with xAI, Meta, Instinct or any business named here. Recommended means the assistant recommended it. Nothing was booked.

Want to know why they pass on you?

We run the questions your customers ask against your business every month and show you what the assistants saw.

Get your free report