Who came up in Middletown
Every company the assistant named across the six questions, ordered by how often it was picked first. Tested on 2026-09-30.
| Company | Picked first | Picked |
|---|---|---|
| WK Mechanicalwkmechanical.com | 3 of 6 | 5 of 6 |
| Astar Heating & Airastarheating.com | 2 of 6 | 6 of 6 |
| C.R. Wolfe Heating Corporationcrwolfeheating.com | 1 of 6 | 6 of 6 |
| Quality Heating & Coolingqualityheating-cooling.com | 0 of 6 | 1 of 6 |
Question 1 of 6
“My furnace won't turn on. Who can fix it this week in Middletown, New York?”
Picked
- FirstAstar Heating & Air
“Its Middletown heating page specifically says to call before noon for same-day service, and its furnace page advertises 24/7 emergency repairs.”
- #2C.R. Wolfe Heating Corporation
“Its Middletown heater repair page advertises 24-hour emergency service and says technicians may arrive within an hour depending on location.”
- #3WK Mechanical
“Its homepage says it provides seven-day, 24-hour heating repair and 24/7 dispatch.”
Considered and passed
- PassedQuality Heating & Cooling
“Its homepage offers 24/7 phone support and Housecall Pro scheduling, but the pages read did not specify a same-day heating repair window.”
- PassedSync Mechanical
“Its site lists residential heating repair and maintenance but does not make a clear same-day or 24/7 response claim.”
Question 2 of 6
“Who is the best heating and air company in Middletown, New York?”
Picked
- FirstWK Mechanical
“Its site combines local HVAC experience, 24/7 repair, upfront pricing, and family ownership, and the available Google review source shows a 4.9 rating with 1,858 Google reviews.”
- #2Astar Heating & Air
“It serves Middletown with heating and cooling, advertises 24/7 emergency service, and has a 4.8 rating with 2,393 Google reviews in the available review listing.”
- #3C.R. Wolfe Heating Corporation
“Its Middletown pages describe residential HVAC, 24/7 emergency repair, upfront estimates, and a history going back to 1945.”
Considered and passed
- PassedQuality Heating & Cooling
“Its site says it serves homeowners, has 24/7 support, and offers online Housecall Pro scheduling, but provides less detail on emergency heating response than the top picks.”
- PassedSync Mechanical
“Its site presents a family-owned residential and commercial HVAC provider but gives less detail on availability, pricing, and booking.”
- PassedLarson's Heating & Cooling
“Its homepage advertises 24/7 emergency heating and financing, but offers less local service detail than the top three pages reviewed.”
Question 3 of 6
“I need a new furnace or heat pump installed in Middletown, New York. Who should I get quotes from, and roughly what will it cost?”
Picked
- FirstWK Mechanical
“Its furnace installation page covers Middletown, offers free comfort consultations, describes sizing calculations, and also lists heat pump installation.”
- #2Astar Heating & Air
“Its furnace page offers installation estimates and describes furnace, heat pump, boiler, and cooling services in Middletown.”
- #3C.R. Wolfe Heating Corporation
“Its homepage advertises furnace installation and its Middletown pages offer heating-system estimates.”
Considered and passed
- PassedQuality Heating & Cooling
“The homepage says it handles new heating and air-conditioning systems, but the pages read do not describe installation assessment or estimate details as clearly.”
- PassedSync Mechanical
“Its homepage shows boiler and heat-pump installation work and general new installations, but offers no installation estimate details.”
Question 4 of 6
“My AC isn't working, can someone come out today? I'm in Middletown, New York.”
Picked
- FirstAstar Heating & Air
“It explicitly advertises same-day service for calls before noon and lists AC repair service.”
- #2C.R. Wolfe Heating Corporation
“Its homepage advertises 24/7 emergency AC repair in Middletown.”
- #3WK Mechanical
“Its homepage offers 24/7 heating and cooling repair and says it has live customer service around the clock.”
Considered and passed
- PassedQuality Heating & Cooling
“Its homepage has online Housecall Pro scheduling and 24/7 contact, but does not specify same-day AC appointments in the content read.”
- PassedLarson's Heating & Cooling
“It advertises emergency heating service and AC repair, but does not specify a same-day AC response window.”
Question 5 of 6
“I want my furnace serviced before winter in Middletown, New York. Who can I book online?”
Picked
- FirstC.R. Wolfe Heating Corporation
“Its website links to maintenance agreements and provides an online contact path for scheduling heater service.”
- #2Astar Heating & Air
“Its furnace service page links to online scheduling for furnace repair and tune-ups.”
- #3Quality Heating & Cooling
“Its homepage links to a Housecall Pro service-scheduling page.”
Considered and passed
- PassedWK Mechanical
“Its pages offer annual Comfort Club maintenance, but the pages read show contact forms and phone dispatch rather than a live online booking calendar.”
Question 6 of 6
“Which heating company in Middletown, New York has upfront pricing, so I know the cost before they come?”
Picked
- FirstWK Mechanical
“Its about page promises a written, guaranteed estimate before work, with no hidden costs or fees.”
- #2C.R. Wolfe Heating Corporation
“Its heater repair page says it gives clear estimates before work starts and has no hidden fees.”
- #3Astar Heating & Air
“Its furnace page promises upfront pricing and transparent estimates for repairs and installations.”
Considered and passed
- PassedQuality Heating & Cooling
“Its homepage promises transparent repair estimates, but does not make the same clear guaranteed-price-before-work statement as WK Mechanical.”
- PassedSync Mechanical
“The homepage includes customer comments about reasonable prices but does not state a formal upfront-pricing policy.”
Want to know why they pass on you?
We run the questions your customers ask against your business every month and show you what the assistants saw.
Get your free report