The October 2026 Picks Index is live. See who Grok, Meta Muse, Instinct, Kat and Fo named across 195 cities and 22 trades.
picked by agents

HVAC city tests · Idaho · one AI assistant's answers, September 2026

Who an AI assistant picked for HVAC in Star, ID

Across six questions, J&D Heating, Cooling & Water was picked 4 times and first 3 times; Siberian Air was picked 4 times and first 2 times. The remaining picks were Fix it Frankie (1), Idaho Plumbing, Heating & Air (1), and Diamond Heating, Cooling, Plumbing & Electric (1).

Who came up in Star

Every company the assistant named across the six questions, ordered by how often it was picked first. Tested on 2026-09-30.

CompanyPicked firstPicked
J&D Heating, Cooling & Watergetjdnow.com4 of 65 of 6
Siberian Airsiberianair.com1 of 65 of 6
Fix it Frankiefixitfrankie.com1 of 61 of 6
BNR Heating and Airbnrhvac.com0 of 61 of 6
Diamond Heating, Cooling, Plumbing & Electricdiamondheatingandcooling.com0 of 61 of 6
Idaho Plumbing, Heating & Airidahoheating.com0 of 61 of 6

Question 1 of 6

“My furnace won't turn on. Who can fix it this week in Star, Idaho?”

Picked

  1. First
    J&D Heating, Cooling & Water
    “Its Star page explicitly offers same-day furnace repair, 24/7 emergency service, and service for all furnace models.”
  2. #2
    Siberian Air
    “It serves Star, prioritizes no-heat calls in winter, and says most service calls are same-day or next-day.”

Considered and passed

  • Passed
    BNR Heating and Air
    “Its Star page offers furnace repair and a lifetime craftsmanship guarantee but does not state a same-day or emergency response time.”
  • Passed
    Idaho Plumbing, Heating & Air
    “Its Star page lists furnace repair and a lifetime guarantee but gives no turnaround or emergency availability.”

Question 2 of 6

“Who is the best heating and air company in Star, Idaho?”

Picked

  1. First
    J&D Heating, Cooling & Water
    “It combines a stated history dating to 1961 with Star-specific repair coverage, same-day availability, emergency service, and a money-back guarantee.”
  2. #2
    BNR Heating and Air
    “Its Star page promises free second opinions on replacements and a lifetime guarantee on its craftsmanship.”

Considered and passed

  • Passed
    Idaho Plumbing, Heating & Air
    “It lists a wide range of HVAC services and a lifetime guarantee, but its Star page provides fewer specific scheduling or price details.”
  • Passed
    Siberian Air
    “It has clear same-day and upfront-pricing claims, but I found less evidence of a long operating history or customer track record in the pages reviewed.”

Question 3 of 6

“I need a new furnace or heat pump installed in Star, Idaho. Who should I get quotes from, and roughly what will it cost?”

Picked

  1. First
    J&D Heating, Cooling & Water
    “It lists furnace replacement and heat-pump installation and has a dedicated Star service page.”
  2. #2
    Siberian Air
    “Its Star page lists furnace installation and heat-pump services, and its main site says quotes are provided in writing.”
  3. #3
    Idaho Plumbing, Heating & Air
    “Its Star page lists heating services and furnace and heat-pump repairs, with a lifetime guarantee on work.”

Considered and passed

  • Passed
    BNR Heating and Air
    “Its Star page clearly discusses repairs and free second opinions on replacements, but the pages reviewed did not establish a specific installation offer or pricing.”

Question 4 of 6

“My AC isn't working, can someone come out today? I'm in Star, Idaho”

Picked

  1. First
    J&D Heating, Cooling & Water
    “It explicitly lists AC repair in Star and states same-day availability and 24/7 emergency service.”
  2. #2
    Siberian Air
    “It offers AC repair in Star and says same-day service is available, with most calls scheduled same-day or next-day.”

Considered and passed

Question 5 of 6

“I want my furnace serviced before winter in Star, Idaho. Who can I book online?”

Picked

  1. First
    Fix it Frankie
    “Its Star page links directly to a Housecall Pro booking page, making it the clearest online booking route found.”
  2. #2
    J&D Heating, Cooling & Water
    “It offers furnace maintenance and lets customers request service online through its form.”
  3. #3
    Siberian Air
    “It lists preventative maintenance plans for Star and provides an online request-service link.”

Considered and passed

  • Passed
    Idaho Plumbing, Heating & Air
    “Its Star page has a contact form, but I did not find a direct appointment calendar or a clear online booking option.”

Question 6 of 6

“Which heating company in Star, Idaho has upfront pricing, so I know the cost before they come?”

Picked

  1. First
    Siberian Air
    “It publishes its $100 service-call fee and says each repair or replacement is quoted in writing before work starts.”
  2. #2
    Diamond Heating, Cooling, Plumbing & Electric
    “Its furnace-repair page says it provides a repair quote before starting and that the quote is the final price.”

Considered and passed

  • Passed
    BNR Heating and Air
    “It promises a fair assessment and lowest cost but does not show a specific service-call fee or written upfront-price policy on its Star page.”
  • Passed
    J&D Heating, Cooling & Water
    “Its Star and furnace pages give service and guarantee details but do not publish a service-call fee or written quote policy.”

Want to know why they pass on you?

We run the questions your customers ask against your business every month and show you what the assistants saw.

Get your free report