The scores
Every assistant, side by side
Each number is a share of the answers in that row. Weighed is businesses named per answer. What every column measures is set out below.
| Assistant | Answers | Weighed | No pick | Own site | Same twice | Reads most | Rewards most |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Meta Muse Sep to Nov 2026 | 10,649 | 5.9 | 6% | 79% | 24% | expertise.com, 11% | Reviews and ratings, 37% |
| Instinct Sep to Nov 2026 | 3,276 | 5.0 | 15% | 82% | 17% | bbb.org, 17% | Price and financing, 53% |
| Fo Sep to Nov 2026 | 1,128 | 5.2 | 7% | 59% | 22% | maps.google.com, 13% | Reviews and ratings, 19% |
| Grok Bot September 2026 | 336 | 12.4 | 0% | 83% | too few | bbb.org, 87% | Licenses and credentials, 91% |
| Kat October 2026 | 135 | 4.8 | 0% | 100% | too few | dermanimedspa.zenoti.com, 15% | Price and financing, 100% |
Too few means under 50 pairs of answers to compare. The months under each name are the rounds it answered in.
Ask twice
No business owns a question
The same question, asked of the same assistant in the same month, usually gets a different first pick. Ask a different assistant and it almost always does. A single check of your business is one draw; how often you are picked over many asks is what decides your share of customers.
Same assistant, asked twice
- Meta Muse (7,944 pairs)24%
- Instinct (519 pairs)17%
- Fo (1,039 pairs)22%
Two assistants, same question
- Instinct and Meta Muse (1,375)7%
- Fo and Meta Muse (601)6%
- Grok Bot and Instinct (286)10%
- Fo and Instinct (267)7%
- Kat and Meta Muse (131)11%
- Instinct and Kat (128)19%
- Grok Bot and Meta Muse (77)6%
- Fo and Kat (63)24%
Method
What each number measures
Every number counts recorded answers to questions customers ask, from our own assistant accounts. No sponsors, no paid placements, and no assistant maker pays to be tested. Every answer is quoted word for word in the Picks Index.
Businesses weighed
- How many businesses an answer names, picked, shortlisted or passed over.
- For you. A long list means you can be in the running and still lose. Being named is not being picked.
Answers with no pick
- Share of answers that named businesses but would not recommend one.
- For you. When an assistant cannot tell businesses apart it picks nobody. Clear facts on your own site break the tie.
Own site read
- Share of its picks whose own website was among the sources it cited.
- For you. How much your website counts next to directories and reviews when this assistant decides.
Leans most on
- The third-party site its answers cite most often, never a business it named.
- For you. The listing to fix first for this assistant.
Rewards most
- The reason its picks give most often, read from the reason it states.
- For you. What to make easy to find on your site and profiles.
Same pick asked twice
- Two answers from the same assistant to the same question in the same month. Share naming the same first pick.
- For you. One check is one draw. Your share of picks over many asks is the number that matters.
Coming next
- Booking. Whether it gets to the confirm step on a business's own booking page, reported as would have booked.
- Facts. Phone numbers, hours and open or closed, checked against the business's own profile.
- Contact. Whether it would call, fill in a form or ask for a quote, and what it needs to do it.
See each assistant's answers on the Picks Index and who each one picked first on the leaderboards.
Want to know why they pass on you?
We run the questions your customers ask against your business every month and show you what the assistants saw.
Get your free report